The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in New York Mills, NY

The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in New York Mills, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


4 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in New York Mills, NY

Sugar-free
GemHidden gem
Sugar, Spice and Nice Things 

5.0

  • Starts at $120
  • Serves New York Mills, NY for additional fees

Sugar, Spice and Nice Things is a small bakeshop located in Hewlett, NY, on the South Shore of Nassau County, proudly serving customers on Long Island, NYC and beyond. We believe wholeheartedly in quality over quantity, so though we be but small, we are mighty! Our intention is to bake as fresh as possible with our quality ingredients for you to enjoy as soon as possible. At Sugar, Spice and Nice Things, we are constantly inspired by nature and appreciate life's great pleasures in the nice simple things. Long Island Choice Awards 2025

Sugar, Spice and Nice Things was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding desserts! They were incredibly responsive and paid close attention to every detail, ensuring our order was perfect. Each piece they handcrafted was exquisitely made and absolutely delicious - my serotonin loved them! The quality and value of their work was top-notch, and we couldn't have been happier. Very professional, tasteful, and you truly can't go wrong with Sugar, Spice and Nice Things for your wedding. Highly recommend!
Samantha, a month ago
Shae's Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves New York Mills, NY

Hello! My name is Shaelyn Oathout. I am the self taught one woman show behind Shae’s Cakes, an in-home bakery based in Poland, NY. I’m so glad you’re here! Shae’s Cakes started early in 2020 as a hobby, but I quickly realized just how passionate I am about starting from scratch, and bringing people’s sweet dreams to life! I look forward to getting to know you, and helping you create tasty memories that will last a lifetime!

Shae’s Cakes made cake pops for our wedding. She made 4 different unique flavors, and they were the most delicious cake pops I’ve ever had! People still talk about them over a year later! It makes a huge difference knowing that the dessert served at my wedding was rememberable. We will be using Shae’s Cakes for all of our events in the future! She is very easy to work with and accommodating.
Andres & B., 3 years ago
Sugar & Slice 
  • Serves New York Mills, NY

Owner Trisha is a formally trained interior designer turned self-taught cake artist. Her passion began after her own wedding to her husband, Travis, in 2009. After spending hours searching for a cake design for her own wedding, Trisha felt inspired by this delicious art form. Trisha decorated her first cake for fun and her new obsession began…Sugar & Slice creations tap into Trisha’s formal training as an interior designer and center on clean lines, elegant textures, and color. We are always looking for a new challenge and are continually investing in new training and technology to keep up with or stay ahead of currents trends.

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near New York Mills, NY

About wedding cakes & desserts in New York Mills, NY

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in New York Mills, NY?

Wedding cake package prices vary.

Do bakers in New York Mills, NY offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 14 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 9 offer Vegan options.3 offer Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in New York Mills, NY?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in New York Mills, NY are The Gingersnap Bakery, BakerBitesCo and Sweet Buckets.

What other New York Mills vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?