The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Puyallup, WA

The Best Italian Wedding Catering in Puyallup, WA

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


15 Wedding Caterers in Puyallup, WA

Italian
Quick responder
Fat Zach's Pizza 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Fat Zach's Wood Fired Pizza debuted in 2018 as a small food cart on the corner of Pioneer and 2nd in downtown Puyallup. As of March 2020, we now offer you the same great pizza in a space where you can sit down and stay awhile located in Sumner, we hope to become a destination point for travelers from around the US - and a bragging right for the residence of Sumner. If you haven't tried us, today is the day!!

Awarded Best of Zola
We booked Fat Zach's Pizza on the recommendation from our venue, and the venue was right! Fat Zach's was easy to communicate with and set up quotes/contracts. They are very experienced so the set-up was easy and required very little attention from us, allowing us to focus on enjoying the celebration. Their delicious pizza was the talk of the event, with guests raving about how good it was. To top it off, they packed up extra pizzas for us at the end of the night so we could continue the party at home. We highly recommend Fat Zach's Pizza for any couple looking for a straightforward and high-quality catering option for their wedding.
Calandra H., a month ago
Quick responder
Mama Stortinis Catering 

5.0

Puyallup, WA
  • Starts at $3,000

Since 1993, Mama Stortini's has been serious about great food, tasty drinks, and sharing it with folks who love the feeling of a homemade meal. Mama Stortini's Catering takes this concept with them wherever they go, so that any celebration is crafted with love, and it shows.

From the moment Our client's book with Mama Stortinis Catering for their wedding, their communication was clear and transparent, putting all minds at ease throughout the entire planning process. The team was attentive, dependable, efficient, and truly committed to ensuring the special day was a success. They constantly went above and beyond, taking care of every detail from set up, to tear down. We loved working with Mama Stortinis and cannot recommend them highly enough - their exceptional service, and delicious food make each event truly unforgettable. BOOK THEM NOW
Mikayla H., 6 months ago
Quick responder
Cindy's Kitchen Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $900
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

We are a small, family business who love cooking southern style, comfort food! We are originally from Texas, so we KNOW what southern food is supposed to taste like! We make everything from scratch and make sure our presentation is beautiful!

Awarded Best of Zola
Cindy and her Team were absolutely amazing. Being celiac, we had a Taco Bar for dinner and Mashed Potato Bar for Cocktail Hour and Cindy was more than happy to walk me through her ingredient and plans which was greatly appreciated. My guests still talk about how amazing the food was, and I don't disagree! Dessert was a cookie Bar. Cindy's team was amazing and more than happy to make all the items gluten free and even used my recipes. The chocolate mousse with raspberries was divine. We couldn't be happier with Cindy and her Team!
Kate M., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Home Bites LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Mike's culinary journey began in his grandmother’s kitchen, where the aroma of her family feasts sparked his love for cooking. With years of experience, he has served as the opening chef at renowned restaurants like Nerai and The Greek Tribeca in NYC. While passionate about Greek and Italian cuisines, Mike has also mastered flavors from Mexican and Middle Eastern kitchens. A graduate of the Art Institute of Colorado, Mike is currently the executive chef and owner of Home Bites. He focuses on creating memorable dining experiences that foster connections and celebrate life’s special moments through food.

Awarded Best of Zola
I had a rehearsal dinner for my son's wedding the night before the big event. We had the food delivered and set up by the staff of Home Bites. They were professional, well dressed and well mannered. And the food was perfect. Thank you Home Bites!
Shawn, 9 months ago
Quick responder
Six Figure Catering 

5.0

  • Serves Puyallup, WA

At Six Figure Catering, we are passionate about crafting unforgettable moments through our exceptional catering services. With a dedication to flavor and presentation, we invite you to embark on a culinary journey that not only satisfies your appetite but also leaves an indelible mark on your memories. Our team of professional chefs and event planners are committed to delivering an exceptional experience to our clients. We take pride in our attention to detail and our ability to cater to any type of event, whether it's a corporate gathering, a wedding, or a private celebration.

Awarded Best of Zola
I had the pleasure of working with the team at Six Figure Catering for a wedding and I must say it was an amazing experience. From there professionalism and personalities to there very delicious food. I would definitely recommend them for any wedding I'm hosting.
Reece, a year ago

How much will your weddingit really cost? Find out now.

New
The Bite Club 

5.0

  • Serves Puyallup, WA

The Bite Club was built on one simple idea: catering should never be boring. 🍷🧀 We bring luxury charcuterie to weddings, showers, parties, and corporate events with a signature PNW aesthetic that’s equal parts earthy, elegant, and show-stopping. From our iconic charcuterie cart to full grazing tables and custom cups, everything we create is curated to look incredible, taste unforgettable, and feel like an experience. We’re here to feed your people, wow your guests, and give you one less thing to stress about.

If you’re looking for something unforgettable for your wedding (or any event), The Bite Club is it! The charcuterie cart is absolutely stunning and the food is out of this world—so fresh, beautifully arranged, and truly delicious! And Azalee? She’s the sweetest human. You can feel the love and care she pours into everything she does, from the thoughtful presentation to the way she connects with people. The Bite Club is more than just food—it's an experience that adds so much joy and beauty to the day. Highly recommend!
Heidi M., 11 days ago
Quick responder
Essence Of The Thymes Catering 

5.0

  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Founded in 2003, Essence of the Thymes is committed to providing extreme service and exemplary food, always served safely and tastefully. Owner Gina Omalanz stepped onto the catering scene with the goal to create a fresh new take on catering that provided delicious, restaurant quality food and service. Friends and family worked together to remodel a kitchen on the downtown Port Orchard Waterfront, and you can still find us there today! What started out as a dream has become a business that feels more like family. We welcome you to become part of the Essence Family!

Awarded Best of Zola
Essence Of The Thymes exceeded all of our expectations. Their communication was clear, helpful, patient and kind - they truly made us feel at ease throughout the entire planning process. On the day of, their team handled everything seamlessly. The food was absolutely incredible - we're still getting compliments from our guests on the salmon and pork belly. It was, without a doubt, the best wedding food we've ever had. We loved working with Gina and cannot recommend Essence highly enough.
E H., a month ago
Quick responder
amores y sabores catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $350
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

As a passionate chef and bartender, I blend culinary artistry with the craft of mixology to create unforgettable experiences. With years of experience catering weddings and special events, I take pride in crafting menus and drinks that tell a story, using fresh, high-quality ingredients to make every bite and sip memorable. My passion lies in curating unique menus and cocktails that reflect the local flavors and the personal stories of each event I cater. My goal is always to bring people together over good food and creative cocktails, leaving guests delighted and events truly exceptional.

We couldn’t be happier with Amores y Sabores Catering for our wedding! We wanted something fun, flavorful, and inclusive for all of our guests — and they delivered beyond our dreams. The taco bar was a huge hit, with perfectly seasoned meats, fresh toppings, and warm tortillas. But what really impressed us was the vegan taco bar — even our non-vegan friends went back for seconds! The flavors were bold, fresh, and beautifully presented. The team was professional, attentive, and made sure everything ran smoothly from start to finish. Our guests are still talking about the food, and we’ll be recommending Amores y Sabores to everyone we know!”
Whitney s., a month ago
Quick responder
Bite Me Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Your Love Story Deserves a Menu to Match At Bite Me Catering, we believe your wedding day should be as unforgettable as the love you’re celebrating. That’s why we go beyond just food—we craft personalized culinary experiences that reflect your unique style, story, and vision. Whether you're dreaming of an elegant plated dinner, a lavish buffet, or interactive food stations that wow your guests, our chef-owned team is here to bring it all to life with flawless execution and heartfelt service.

Bite Me Catering and Chef Cher were absolutely amazing. Every meeting with Cher, she was enthusiastic, accommodating, and over-the-top organized. She was easy to reach and communicate with, always wanted to help and meet my needs the best she could, and her charcuterie was off the charts beautiful AND delicious!!! I cannot recommend Bite Me enough and thank them for their excellent work!!
Rylee R., 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Calvary Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Calvary Catering is a woman owned/operated business. At Calvary we strive for excellence to provide a memorable event for couples and their guest. As I am married and it is one day to never forget. Calvary caters to your needs and desires. Making a point to get to know each client intimately to fulfill their needs.

Calvary did our catering for our company and killed it! Food was amazing, service was great, I highly recommend Ashley and Calvary Catering
Anthony, 7 months ago
Quick responder
Red's Kitchen and Catering 

5.0

  • Serves Puyallup, WA

Reds Kitchen and Catering is built on our dedication to the art of crafting exceptional cuisine. We are proud to work with local farmers and artisanal food creators for quality ingredients. These go into fresh and seasonal menus that respect sustainability even as they feed you and your guests. Woman-owned and operated, with over 20 years of culinary experience and excellence!

Lisa let us come to do a tasting in advance which gave us confidence in our choice. Red's Kitchen was not only more cost competitive than other options, but the quality, taste, and aesthetics of the ingredients and dishes was incredible and they were willing to come out to Mt. Rainier as part of the process to cater to our wedding. They came early on wedding day and set up and were pleasant to talk to and a welcome part of the party! Would recommend to anyone.
Michael M., a month ago
Quick responder
Twist Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Puyallup, WA for additional fees

We cater to peoples needs by exceptional service and Elegant food, exceeding peoples expectations by hospitality, communication and passion. My staff and team will always welcome you and make you feel like you picked the right leadership to best serve you and your event.

Awarded Best of Zola
Twist catered our wedding and were absolutely phenomenal! Joel and his team were patient and flexible the whole time and worked with us to create our perfect menu. They even went above and beyond, fulling all of our special requests. Our planner complimented that Twist was easy to work with, and loads of our guest's shared how much they loved the food. Even when the venue's representative proved difficult to work with, Twist stayed professional all the way through. LGBTQ friendly
Rachel C., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Makers Pizza Co. 

5.0

  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Puyallup, WA for additional fees

At Makers Pizza Co. Catering, we specialize in handcrafted Italian and Latin-inspired pizzas that bring bold flavors and cultural flair to every event. From classic Margheritas to spicy chorizo delights, we serve passion in every slice. Perfect for weddings, parties, and corporate events!

Makers Pizza Co. was the perfect choice for our wedding catering needs. From the very first interaction, their communication style was attentive, transparent, and responsive, putting us at ease throughout the planning process. The quality of their work was truly remarkable - they crafted an exclusive, professional menu that was both desire-able and priceless. On the day of, they were able to make every meal special without a rush, serving everything in a timely manner and including options for all dietary needs of our guests. The Makers Pizza Co. team was friendly, bilingual, clean, and highly adaptable, ensuring our special day went off without a hitch. We couldn't be happier with their incredible service and contributions to making our wedding day so memorable.
Destiny, 3 months ago
GemHidden gem
Old Ballard Catering Co. 

5.0

  • Starts at $10,000
  • Serves Puyallup, WA for additional fees

At Old Ballard Catering Co., our motto is "Life Deserves To Be Delicious" and this could not be more true than on your wedding day! Our team of hospitality obsessed, industry professionals are well versed in every part of the wedding planning process. From custom menus and tastings, to space and rental coordination, vendor recommendations and more, we would be honored to be a part of such a special time in your life!

I cannot say enough good things about Old Ballard Catering Co.! Old Ballard recently helped to cater our wedding and was amazing throughout the whole process! When our venue suddenly shut down in January and we had to find a new venue, our new venue recommended Old Ballard Catering Co. and I cannot be happier. They jumped into action helping us figure out our new plan and what rentals we would need, offering a delicious tasting of our wedding food which made us so excited for the big day (I still dream about their Soba Noodle Salad), and asking and answering all of the critical questions leading up to the big day. Day of, Jo Ann and Pete were the first smiles I saw, offering a big hug and congrats as I walked through the door before they jetted off to make our wedding dream come to life. I truly cannot recommend Old Ballard Catering Co. and their team enough! A BIG thanks to the whole team for making our special day magical!
Elise A., 4 days ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Puyallup, WA

About wedding caterers in Puyallup, WA

What types of caterers are in Puyallup, WA?

What other Puyallup vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?